Archive for the ‘Events’ Category

The best of Anglicon 2017   Leave a comment

 

Sylvester McCoy playing the spoons to live accompaniment was definitely a highlight of the event. (Is it just me or does he look a bit like Mark Hamill these days?)

Two years ago, at our first Anglicon, we saw Colin Baker, Katy Manning, and Sophie Aldred. As guests these three remain unsurpassed. Our delight in them is unmarred and unrestrained and may forever remain unmatched.

This year’s guests included Sylvester above, Peter Davison, and Bentley “the poor Corgi actor,” star of Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency alongside Elijah Wood and that other guy. Bentley’s performance was of course flawless: he and his little sister put on a show for fans, and were joined by friends in the community for a Corgi parade in full holiday regalia, led of course by a Dalek. You can’t go wrong with Corgis.

The human guests were enjoyable, though somewhat less flawless. McCoy is delightful, hilarious, and energetic – he carried a microphone around the audience to answer questions himself, rather than let the moderator do it. He had some good stories about his acting career, including a production of King Lear with Ian McKellan and something weird with Robert Picardo in Edinburgh. He refused to answer a child’s question about his favorite companion, on the grounds that choosing one would not only be unkind but impossible. However, he was a bit more lecherous than I would prefer, making sexual jokes about both the new Doctor and Rose. Neither Baker nor Davison so much as dropped hints in that direction. For that I am grateful to them.

I did appreciate that both classic actors value Rose properly – both as a well-rounded companion and for her contribution to the success of the modern show. Apparently Davison’s sons – then 6 and 8 or so – loved her dearly. Hearing rumors that she was to die at the end of her run, Davison sent a concerned email to showrunner Russell T. Davies. Reportedly Davies replied, “You killed Adric, what do you care?”

Davison was also a source of concern. Going into the event, I considered not attending his Q&A sessions, knowing that fans would bring up both his (questionable) reaction to the new Doctor and his (TMI) personal life. Which they did – though I’m glad I went anyway, as he was very funny (mostly at Colin Baker’s expense) and had some great insights into the JNT era – particularly, the effect of JNT’s unfamiliarity with sci fi on the quality of stories at the time. I enjoyed his description of his time on All Creatures Great and Small as “up a cow.” That show – as well as the more recent Last Detective – might be worth investigating.

He did stand by his assessment of Whittaker’s casting as a loss of a role model for boys, pointing out how rare non-violent heroes are. He also expressed disappointment in the trend of politics infiltrating television. He did not seem to consider the paucity of heroic female role models, or understand that casting another white man would be as political a choice as anything else. I considered bringing up these questions, but decided I would rather just move on from them.

He also raised what I would consider a more valid concern: what does the BBC do next? If casting a woman were a purely points-scoring, checking-the-box maneuver, and the show goes right back to another 50 years of white men, then it was all meaningless. Likewise, 50 years of women in the role might serve more as book-balancing than valid casting. He is right, I think, that either of these would be a mistake. However, he is operating on the assumption that casting Jodie was an “inorganic,” forced decision. I think Chibnall put more thought into it than Davison wants to give him credit for, and that this new casting opens the door for all kinds of actors in the role: a mix of men and women of various ethnic (but invariably British*) and social backgrounds should provide lots of interesting Doctors over the next half century.

(I did observe, and one fan mentioned, that Moffat said some things recently about this topic. I did not read whatever it was; Moffat often opens his mouth when he shouldn’t, and I have no interest in his opinions on most matters.)

Regarding the personal questions, which I also didn’t want to hear, Davison is by now so used to being asked about his fan-favorite son-in-law that he actually bulldozed a question about “The Doctor’s Daughter” casting to talk about later events. On the other hand, his stories about the budding acting career of his 18-year-old son – and his humor at himself in that regard – were both amusing and perfectly appropriate.

Overall, neither actor was as funny or as sincere as Colin Baker, and of course there’s no beating Katy Manning. ❤

The other highlight of Anglicon is of course the costumes. Female Fifth Doctors outnumbered all others. There were a couple of excellent Cybermen – one a child who entered the costume contest as “Bill Potts” – and an astounding Empress of Mars. (She should have won the contest, really, but the top prize went to an unfamiliar character presumably from Red Dwarf.) The panels this year were also of higher quality than previous. We learned about reconstruction of lost episodes, played improv games, and heard about Douglas Adams from a writer who had conducted numerous personal interviews with him over the years. (Some of that material appears in DWM #313, which I will have to try and get my hands on.)

However, I don’t know if we’ll go next year. Seattle is becoming a more and more difficult trip, and we have some wonderful local cons bringing great Doctors right to our door. But I’m not sorry we went, and another visit is certainly not out of the question.

 

 

*Yes, I know some people feel that limiting casting to British actors is as bad as limiting it to white men, but I disagree. Doctor Who is an undeniably British show, full of British jokes and Britishisms in spite of its international following. However, the UK is 50% women and as much as 40% non-white in some areas. These people are British too, and the show does well to reflect that.

Advertisements

Posted December 13, 2017 by Elisabeth in Classic, Conventions, Events

Tagged with , , ,

Invasion of Gallifrey   Leave a comment

Two weeks ago we watched “The Invasion of Time” on the big screen with a roomful of other nerds. The story, featuring Four, Leela, and K-9, takes place almost entirely on Gallifrey.

The serial aired in February and March 1978. A year and a half earlier television-time, the Doctor abandoned Sarah Jane in Aberdeen, telling her that no humans were permitted on Gallifrey. This time he drags Leela along without a qualm. Does he no longer care? Was he tired of Sarah? Or did writers give little thought to the disposal of companions? The last seems most likely, given the departure of Leela at the end of this story: her relationship with Andred* lacks any foundation or expression on screen, but in the end she gives up everything to be with him. Susan’s romance with David Campbell (“Dalek Invasion of Earth”) has more substance to it, but still she is devastated to be left behind.

Gallifrey itself is an interesting place. The privileged population lives entirely indoors, encased in rules and intrigue. Outside is a place of banishment, where survival is improbable – except by a band of savages with whom Leela quickly identifies. The Doctor has come to claim his Presidency, while secretly working to thwart an invasion. Various bureaucrats battle him, and one another, for leadership and control. Pandemonium, of course, ensues.

After a slow start the story is well-paced and engaging. In spite of its length and the lateness of the hour we were never bored. Necessarily limited and repetitive locations are exploited for their humorous potential. Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor and John Arnatt’s Borusa delight with their mutual discourtesy and unlikely alliance. Overall, it’s good classic DW fun.

* In spite of ignominious beginnings, Leela’s relationship with Andred sparked a whole world of ideas exploited by Big Finish for their licensed audio stories. (See Life on Gallifrey.)

Posted December 15, 2016 by Elisabeth in Classic, Companions, Events, Guest stars

Tagged with ,

Class and other fun   Leave a comment

Last week we watched the first episode of the new DW spinoff, Class. It was, as I had begun to suspect, more Torchwood than SJA, and also quite well written. The characters are good, the conflict is good, and the Doctor is icing on the alien cake. I look forward to the rest of the series.

Last night my meetup group saw the newly released animated version of “Power of the Daleks” in the theater. I continue to be impressed with the Troughton era. In spite of a slow start, mediocre animation, and 60s cheese, the serial was quite engaging. The story is tight and well paced, never dragging like some classics tend to. The background artwork is beautiful. The Daleks are terrifying as always, but also sneaky and underhanded and occasionally hilarious: this is the first appearance of the serving-Daleks seen in “Victory of the Daleks.” The showing was followed by a brief making-of video featuring Nick Briggs and several members of the animation team, as well as a few from the original. Just as if we’d watched at home on DVD, but bigger. 🙂

We have lots more Doctor coming up this month. Next week the meetup will watch “Boom Town” and “Bad Wolf.” I wasn’t sure about splitting up the series finale, but “Parting of the Ways” will be paired up with “The Christmas Invasion” just in time for the holidays, so I think I can live with it. Then at the end of the month, our local old-school movie theater will be showing “The Invasion of Time” complete with period commercials. We saw “Genesis of the Daleks” there last year, and it was great fun. I haven’t seen “Invasion,” and we’ve seen very little of Leela so far, so we’re definitely looking forward to it.

On the topic of Christmas specials and similar fun, I have mixed feelings about the one upcoming. I was hoping to meet Pearl this holiday, but she will not appear. I was not as thrilled with Nardole as many apparently were, and I wouldn’t have chosen him as a recurring character. I don’t like how guy-heavy the story appears to be. On the other hand I love cheesy superhero stuff, and Christmas specials are always great fun. I’ll go into it with an open mind.

(On that note, I get surveys from the BBC about upcoming events, and I gave them an earful about the testosterone ratio of the holiday special. It was after that, I note, that the nameless young woman began to appear in the promotional material.)

An added bonus, for those who watched Doctor Who: The World Tour: “Doctor Mysterio” is the Spanish name for Doctor Who, and has its own mariachi filk captured on film. 🙂

Posted November 15, 2016 by Elisabeth in Christmas Specials, Classic, Commentary, Events

Tagged with ,

Well that was different.   2 comments

This week we attended what might have been the oddest Doctor Who event ever. A local wine shop dedicated to pairing its wines with the perfect food or the perfect social occasion has branched out into character pairings. Characters from Harry Potter, Firefly, Game of Thrones, and many more have been matched with zippy Rieslings and dour French Bordeaux. The idea is to taste the character of the wine and consider what traits it shares with characters from popular culture. This week the good Doctor and his friends got a turn.

For example, Clara Oswald was paired with a Pinot Noir Rose described as “energetic, intelligent, sassy, cute,” among other things; Jack Harkness with a “flirtatious, brave, tenacious, worldly, devious” Saro Djablo with an appropriate demon on the label. River Song’s Washington Riesling was “flirty, strong, [and] unpredictable” while the TARDIS was matched with a one of a kind Obac described as “mercurial, temperamental, feisty, [and big-hearted].” The Doctor himself was paired with a Cabernet Franc/Malbec blend described as “stern, gruff, [and] punk rock.” It was a mad range of wines, and great fun tasting for familiar traits. It was also unlike anything I’ve done before.

We wrapped up the evening with trivia. I handily won, going home at the end of an enjoyable night with yet another book for my collection.

People are going to start thinking I’m a nerd.

Posted November 5, 2016 by Elisabeth in Events

Tagged with , , ,

Never too late   Leave a comment

It’s been several weeks since we gathered for “Father’s Day” and “Enemy of the World,” but here I am at last.

“Father’s Day” remains a favorite. Rose learns that her father is not who she thought he was; that her mother lied; that her parents are only human. That her parents are wonderful, fallible people who love her and each other. She faces the brutal consequences of a thoughtless act of love. The Doctor’s rage, while genuine, is only momentary; he is a man who makes mistakes, who thoughtlessly loves again and again in his life. He does everything he can to save Rose’s father for her – an ordinary man, the most important thing in the universe – and though he fails, his efforts bring them closer together.

Pete himself is outstanding. He is a failure, and he knows it. His marriage is on the brink. But he quickly figures out that he is the key to everything, and selflessly gives his life for the women he loves so dearly. His speech to Rose about all the extra hours he got is one of the most moving moments ever on television.

After that emotional wringer, “The Enemy of the World” is great fun. One of the two lost stories found recently in Nigeria, this six-parter features Patrick Troughton as both hero and villain. It’s silly in places – there’s a line about a disused yeti – and deadly serious in others, and though it’s among the longer serials it never lags. Troughton is a delight, well deserving of this showcase for his substantial talent. I’m reminded of Orphan Black, where one actress plays several characters who also play each other; the characters remain distinct, even when hiding in another’s skin.

Up next we’ll pass on a classic story in favor of two-parter “The Empty Child” and “The Doctor Dances.” As Captain Jack just got his own Torchwood series on Big Finish, it’ll be great fun to see his origin again. Mostly, though, I’m looking forward to Nancy.

doctor-who-the-empty-child-nancy

Everybody lives!

Timey wimey   Leave a comment

It seems I neglected to write up our most recent meetup.

Nearly two months ago we gathered for “The Long Game” followed by “The Greatest Show in the Galaxy.” Husband and I skipped last month’s viewing of Doctor Who: The Movie; we have it on DVD, and neither the film nor the venue are favorites of mine. (The venue switched temporarily from my beloved nerdy, British-beer-serving fish and chip shop, probably due to severe crowding and service issues at the prior gathering.)

The venue’s issues failed to detract from my enjoyment of Rose’s first visit to Satellite 5. The episode of course features excellent guest stars: Simon Pegg is flawless and Christine Adams’ Cathica is a longtime favorite. (I squee’d when Adams appeared on Agents of SHIELD.) I love Rose’s character development in this ep, and the progression of her relationship with the Doctor. I love that Adam’s greed and self-centeredness actually cost him. More recent companions get away with all manner of misbehavior, but here Adam – and soon Rose, in the upcoming “Father’s Day” – suffer brutal consequences for their mistakes.

I’m not sure what led the organizer to choose “The Greatest Show in the Galaxy” as a companion piece. It was time for a Seventh Doctor outing; it’s possible he’s thrown connection out the window and just picked an ep he liked. This one is extremely strange. There were jokes about what happens when you “drop acid and make a TV show.” I’m sure it was all very characteristic of the 80’s. The first half is rambling and hard to follow. However, the resolution is classic Sylvester McCoy: he looks small and harmless, but you really don’t want to find yourself on his bad side.

Overall, in spite of the service issues and pseudo-drug flashbacks, the evening was a fun one.

Next week we’ll see “Father’s Day” and “The Enemy Within.” The first is an old favorite, written by the spectacular Paul Cornell.* The second is one of the lost serials recently found in Nigeria of all places; I haven’t seen it yet but have been looking forward to it for some time. Patrick Troughton plays the Doctor as well as the enemy, a performance I can’t wait to see. (Precursor to Matt Smith’s Cyberplanner perhaps?) The original venue has been restored, now that it’s (more than) warm enough to use the large rear patio and the service issues have hopefully been addressed.

DW, Boddington’s on tap, classic fish & chips. What could be better?

 

*Paul Cornell is also responsible for “Human Nature/Family of Blood” – both the Seventh Doctor novel and the S3 two-parter featuring Ten and Martha – the excellent Four Doctors comic series, the Shadow Police series of novels – some of the best urban fantasy of all time – and one of my favorite episodes of Elementary, as well as a plethora of Doctor Who novels, comics, and other things I haven’t read yet.

Posted August 18, 2016 by Elisabeth in Classic, Events, Season 1

Tagged with , ,

The best of New Who   Leave a comment

A while back I considered whether S9 might be my new favorite. The writing, particularly of the first two and last two stories, seemed to reach new levels of depth and richness. The season is not without its flaws, but its best bits stand out brightly.

As my meetup group progresses through S1, for many years uncontested in its top spot, I find little to criticize. While its peaks may not reach the heights S9 achieves, nor does it suffer its slips.

Most recently we watched the first New Who two-parter, “Aliens of London/World War Three.” Best remembered for its farting aliens, the episode did not endure in my mind as anything great. On the rewatch, however, it turns out to be the showcase of some excellent material:

  • The development of Rose’s relationship with Jackie and Mickey, and the grounding of her character
  • The introduction of Harriet Jones, “MP Flydale North”
  • The first New Who appearance of UNIT
  • “Mickey the idiot” saving the world from his home PC
  • The beginning of trust between Mickey and the Doctor
  • The foundation of a friendship between Mickey and Jackie, which endures throughout the RTD era.
  • The Doctor’s confession of the truth behind his adventuring:
World War Three (3)

“This is my life, Jackie – it’s not fun, it’s not smart, it’s just standing up and making a decision because nobody else will.”

  • Rose’s courage and quick thinking in the face of death

Even the farting aliens, something I imagine RTD dreamed up to satisfy his internal (and eternal) nine-year-old, have a scientific reason for their ridiculousness: the gas exchange that allows their enormous bodies to fit inside a suit of human skin. Not only that, but the fact of the farting helps the Doctor determine the nature of the enemy in time to save Mickey and Jackie – or in time to help them save themselves. This balance of horror, silliness, and heart is one of Doctor Who‘s strongest features. I can’t find fault with Russell’s choice.

We haven’t rewatched S9 yet, and we’re only a little way into S1. Time will tell if Nine, Rose, and Russell will retain their throne or if Twelve will manage to unseat them.